web analytics

In a recent column in Healthy Debate, patient advocates Zal Press and Dawn Richards make a strong case for creating a minister’s patient and family advisory council. The concept is admirable and long overdue. But to ensure that it works, and is not just more window dressing, the current reality of patient and family healthcare interaction also needs fundamental change. Here’s the comment we posted in that regard in response to the Press/Richards initiative.

Who could disagree with the idea of according patients and families the role they deserve in every aspect of healthcare policy and delivery? But a seat at the table, where patients and families have a genuinely transformative voice at least equal to all the other healthcare inputs government receives? Not likely to happen.

The fact is patients and families who advocate for recognition and respect have never been welcome in the building, much less in the inner sanctum where healthcare policy is created. And there is a yawning gap between the theory of patient and family advocacy and what actually occurs in the clinical setting that is likely to keep it that way.

Just after I discovered my mother, then 89, had been left flat on her back while on life support in one of Canada’s leading trauma centres, with pools of fluid overflowing from her mouth onto her gown and bed, I saw all these posters on the walls reminding clinicians about the dangers of ventilator-associated pneumonia. Keeping the patient’s bed at a proper angle and not leaving them lying flat was at the top of the list of things to do. But in my mother’s case, her care team didn’t, and she developed ventilator-associated pneumonia. It was a pretty easy patient safety protocol to follow, except this giant teaching hospital not only could not be bothered, but it strenuously resented being questioned as to why it departed from this standard, while making me out to be the offending party. I didn’t know it at the time, of course, but this was just the beginning of a long cascade of breakdowns and errors — for which there was never any apology or truthful explanation — that eventually left my mother terribly disabled.

Odd, perhaps, but I didn’t find the other messages on the walls that encouraged patients and families to speak up and voice their concerns to be particularly consoling. It takes more than a willingness on the part of walls to listen in order to put patients and families first.

The point is that until the infrastructure of healthcare accountability, which is currently crumbling under the weight of entrenched professional interests, hospital cost-cutting measures and a growing army of high-priced lawyers who are paid with public funds to help hide inconvenient truths, is rebuilt, no amount of table talk is going to make a difference in the experience of patients and families. Only strongly voiced public pressure, and an unrelenting focus on the human and financial costs of avoidable hospital errors — the third leading cause of death in Canada and the United States — and the culture of cover-up that allows them to continue, will achieve that goal.

Where you get to sit depends on where you stand in the advocacy of patient protection. And for too many, that means being left out in the cold.

A world-class medical error

(Published in The Huffington Post, October 8, 2014) Thomas Eric Duncan, the patient who was sent home by a Texas hospital even while presenting with the early stages of the Ebola virus, has died. Each day, families around the world face the tragedy of medical errors and hospital mistakes that end in death or extreme …

Read the full article →

A Summer’s Conversations on Patient Safety

We spent a lot of time over the past few months listening to and talking with patients and families from Canada, the U.S. and Europe about patient safety. The common theme of the conversations is that healthcare systems need to do a whole lot better in protecting patients from avoidable harm, or worse, and when …

Read the full article →

Good Luck, Dr. Hoskins

Canada has a new leader in its healthcare system.  Dr. Eric Hoskins is Ontario’s new minister of health and in that task will oversee the country’s largest and most expensive system.  We hope that Dr. Hoskins’ appointment will signal a new chapter in the relationship with patients and families and especially those whose experiences with …

Read the full article →

June 6, 1944 | The Day the Greatest Generation Stood as One on the Beaches of Courage and Freedom

                                              hhh hhh hhh hh hhhhh kkkk A tribute to the Greatest Generation, and the valiant efforts of all those at home and in the theatres of war whose efforts we give special …

Read the full article →

Coming Soon: Lessons for Canada’s largest teaching hospital

What Sunnybrook’s board of directors needs to learn about respecting patients and families and creating a culture of honesty and transparency that enhances patient safety and reduces medical harm.

Read the full article →

What are Canadian Hospitals Hiding?

It is time to put “national” back into Canada’s healthcare system and to give Canadians the straight goods on its performance. Shocking allegations have surfaced in connection with VA hospitals in eight U.S. states. Families and whistleblowers alike claim that secret lists of patients were kept in order to keep them off the books and make …

Read the full article →

A Mother’s Day Tribute

  I am so very proud of my mother who, today, at the age of 92, is living proof that it is possible for the elderly to be more than a statistic and that the will to live, and the love of family, can be among the most potent of life-saving medications.  She is also …

Read the full article →

Ontario’s CCACs reflect shocking culture of excess at the top, paid for by most vulnerable

The CCAC concept was created by bureaucrats and  exhibits some of the worst attributes of bureaucracies.  But it works very well for the bureaucratic mentality that runs it. _____________________________________ EDITOR’S NOTE:  The piece below, and the earlier posting on CCAC excess and abuse, have generated an absolutely amazing number of emails from readers endorsing our conclusions and sharing …

Read the full article →

Time to end Ontario’s home care scam

It’s hard enough for a family to see a loved one at home suffering because CCAC services that were promised were never delivered. But it is an outrage that the members of our Greatest Generation, who saved democracy and rebuilt the economy after World War II, in the waning of their years have become pawns …

Read the full article →